Should random collection, no-theme imagesets be considered garbage?

Should random collection, no-theme imagesets be considered garbage?

Yes
No
Other opinion (see comments)

Total Votes: 27

Oct 6 2010, 21:06 Post #1
Red of EHCOVE Viceroy of Oook & EHCOVE cofounder Group: Gold Star Club Posts: 9,492 Joined: 28-April 07 Level 365 (Godslayer) +K	A lot of imagesets (our 3rd largest type of uploads) are "my favorite hentai images for you" kind of trash, hiding better galleries, or those in need of recategorization (see for example how many imagesets need magic reclassing to non-h). So let's answer one question that's been popping up recently: should we expunge non-themed imagesets? By theme I mean character, parody, fetish, and anything similar. If an imageset has a theme, keep it. But it is just a random collection of images... booru-'s are that a'way, as far as I am concerned. Also, feel free to offer opinion on the minimum number of images imagesets should have, and on whether they should fall into the limited number of upload slots restriction (like misc and non-h do, and I think asian porn may as well... not sure if there are restrictions on cosplay and western...). This post has been edited by Red_Piotrus: Oct 6 2010, 21:11 -------------------- Tag check Backlogs: expunge rename K+ Created tags you can blame me for: clamp (def, use), clone (def, use), closed eyes (def, use), dismantling (def, use), facial hair (def, use), fishnets (def, use), hair buns (def, use), headless (def, use), hood (def, use), horns (def, use), kemonomimi (def, use), missing cover (def, use), sarashi (def, use), sketch lines (def, use), soushuuhen (def, use), tail (def, use) Tags significantly changed: filming (def, use), large tattoo (def, use), exhibitionism Interesting tag proposals/revisions under discussion (please consider commenting): anon, below knee boots, calendar, clueless (aka naive), couple (two people having sex), eye-covering bang, hat, helmet, husband and wife (aka married couple, spouse), phone/camera scan, under knee high boots / below knee boots, watching Tags I am thinking about proposing (be scared / PM me with comments/examples): butt plug, covered in cum, halo, high heels, metal bikini, mentally retarded, miniskirt, ribbon headband, samurai, self-sucking, socks, flora/vegetable insertion (please post examples here), veil Play some games and rip them for the galleries My scan commissions Can you read Japanese? Do you want lots of GP/creds/hath? Visit our bounty subforum! Extra rewards if you translate posted EHCOVE bounties or my proposed projects here! (Also looking for editors and proofreaders). Celebrate EHCOVE's 5th Anniversary and check out our first exclusive Artist/Game CG set release, the OPTC Nude Project: A Man's Dream

Posts in this topic

Red_Piotrus Should random collection, no-theme imagesets be considered garbage? Oct 6 2010, 21:06

3d0xp0xy [quote name='Red_Piotrus' post='825195' date='Oct ... Oct 6 2010, 21:54

rookie84 [quote name='3d0xp0xy' post='825238' date='Oct 7 2... Oct 6 2010, 23:52

Ichizon Well, I don't personally spend time viewing th... Oct 6 2010, 22:39

Sayo Aisaka I suggested recently that image sets should earn G... Oct 6 2010, 23:01

kingwolf People upload galleries only for the GP?! :b... Oct 7 2010, 06:33

Red_Piotrus [quote name='kingwolf' post='825692' date='Oct 6 2... Oct 7 2010, 18:29

Dlaglacz [quote name='Red_Piotrus' post='826154' date='Oct ... Oct 8 2010, 00:10

Red_Piotrus [quote name='Dlaglacz' post='826335' date='Oct 7 2... Oct 8 2010, 01:58

Dlaglacz [quote name='Red_Piotrus' post='826434' date='Oct ... Oct 8 2010, 12:57

Red_Piotrus [quote name='Dlaglacz' post='826959' date='Oct 8 2... Oct 8 2010, 19:12

Dlaglacz [quote name='Red_Piotrus' post='827224' date='Oct ... Oct 8 2010, 22:32

Red_Piotrus [quote name='Dlaglacz' post='827357' date='Oct 8 2... Oct 8 2010, 23:14

Shadow Weaver [quote name='Red_Piotrus' post='827374' date='Oct ... Oct 9 2010, 01:35

Battle_Hunter well, there's the "my favorite pics... Oct 7 2010, 07:04

PsychoticSoul Agree with the OP, and I happen to like a lot of t... Oct 7 2010, 17:43

3d0xp0xy [quote name='PsychoticSoul' post='826112' date='Oc... Oct 7 2010, 18:04

PsychoticSoul [quote name='3d0xp0xy' post='826120' date='Oct 7 2... Oct 7 2010, 18:25

Tenboro Not yet, anyway. Oct 8 2010, 00:52

bladejtr [quote name='Tenboro' post='826364' date='Oct 7 20... Oct 11 2010, 09:29

3d0xp0xy I don't think it would be wise to start replac... Oct 8 2010, 02:58

PsychoticSoul [quote name='3d0xp0xy' post='826516' date='Oct 8 2... Oct 8 2010, 04:01

Tenseigamoon Most of the image sets being uploaded absolutely s... Oct 10 2010, 03:37

Anto of the Sand Don't like image sets in general. It's jus... Oct 10 2010, 07:44

Red_Piotrus It does seem like we are reaching a consensus that... Oct 11 2010, 06:23

3d0xp0xy Start knitting sock puppets. :duck: Oct 11 2010, 10:03

Boggyb As awful as imagesets can be, nothing good will co... Oct 11 2010, 10:10

bladejtr Subjective is always bad, it assumes common sense ... Oct 11 2010, 10:12

Boggyb It's even worse than that. It assumes common s... Oct 11 2010, 10:16

shintsu nice to see that there is some planning on the ima... Oct 11 2010, 21:46

Red_Piotrus [quote name='shintsu' post='830171' date='Oct 11 2... Oct 11 2010, 23:19

« Next Oldest · Site Discussion & Help Desk · Next Newest »

1 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)

1 Members: Therain_Chen

Display Mode: Switch to: Standard · Switch to: Linear+ · Outline

Track this topic · Email this topic · Print this topic · Subscribe to this forum